History Philosophy

Download The Pseudoscience Wars: Immanuel Velikovsky and the Birth of by Michael D. Gordin PDF

By Michael D. Gordin

Properly analyzed, the collective mythological and non secular writings of humanity show that round 1500 BC, a comet swept perilously with reference to Earth, triggering frequent usual mess ups and perilous the destruction of all lifestyles earlier than settling into sun orbit as Venus, our nearest planetary neighbor.
 
Sound fantastic? good, from 1950 till the past due Nineteen Seventies, a big variety of humans begged to vary, as they wolfed Immanuel Velikovsky’s significant best-seller, Worlds in Collision, insisting that maybe this polymathic philosopher held the major to a brand new technology and a brand new historical past. Scientists, nonetheless, assaulted Velikovsky’s booklet, his fans, and his press mercilessly from the get-go. In The Pseudoscience Wars, Michael D. Gordin resurrects the mostly forgotten determine of Velikovsky and makes use of his unusual profession and strangely influential writings to discover the altering definitions of the road that separates valid clinical inquiry from what's deemed bunk, and to teach how very important this question continues to be to us at the present time. Drawing on a wealth of formerly unpublished fabric from Velikovsky’s own documents, Gordin offers a behind-the-scenes background of the writer’s profession, from his preliminary burst of good fortune via his becoming impact at the counterculture, heated public battles with such luminaries as Carl Sagan, and eventual eclipse. alongside the way in which, he deals attention-grabbing glimpses into the histories and results of alternative fringe doctrines, together with creationism, Lysenkoism, parapsychology, and more—all of that have wonderful connections to Velikovsky’s theories.
 
Science this day is hardly ever universally safe, and scientists appear themselves beset by way of critics, denialists, and people they label “pseudoscientists”—as visible all too truly in battles over evolution and weather swap. The Pseudoscience Wars simultaneously unearths the extraordinary chilly conflict roots of our modern problem and issues readers to another method of drawing the road among wisdom and nonsense.

Show description

Read or Download The Pseudoscience Wars: Immanuel Velikovsky and the Birth of the Modern Fringe PDF

Best history & philosophy books

Fabulous science

The nice biologist Louis Pasteur suppressed 'awkward' information since it did not aid the case he used to be making. John Snow, the 'first epidemiologist' was once doing not anything others had no longer performed earlier than. Gregor Mendel, the meant 'founder of genetics' by no means grasped the basic ideas of 'Mendelian' genetics.

Fabulous Science: Fact and Fiction in the History of Scientific Discovery

"Fabulous technological know-how unearths lots of those findings to the final reader for the 1st time. frequently startling and continually enchanting, they express that a few of our most vital clinical theories have been firstly permitted simply simply because well-known scientists fudged facts, pulled rank, or have been propped up via spiritual and political elites.

Divine Action and Natural Selection - Science, Faith and Evolution

The controversy among divine motion, or religion, and ordinary choice, or technological know-how, is garnering large curiosity. This e-book ventures way past the standard, contrasting American Protestant and atheistic issues of view, and in addition comprises the views of Jews, Muslims, and Roman Catholics. It comprises arguments from a few of the proponents of clever layout, creationism, and Darwinism, and likewise covers the delicate factor of the way to include evolution into the secondary college biology curriculum.

Chaos Bound: Orderly Disorder in Contemporary Literature and Science

Whilst that the learn of nonlinear dynamics got here into its personal in the
sctences, the point of interest of literary experiences shifted towards neighborhood, fragmentary modes of
analysis within which texts have been now not considered as deterministic or predictable.
N. Katherine Hayles right here investigates parallels among modern literature and important conception and the rising interdisciplinary box referred to as the
science of chaos. She unearths in either clinical and literary discourse new interpretations of chaos, that's visible now not as disease yet as a locus of maximum
information and complexity. the hot paradigm of chaos comprises parts that,
Hayles exhibits, have been glaring in literary idea and literature earlier than they became
prominent within the sciences. She asserts that such similarities among the natural
and human sciences are the outcome no longer of direct impression yet of roots in a
common cultural matrix.
Hayles lines the evolution of the concept that of chaos and evaluates the paintings of
such theorists as Prigogine, Feigenbaum, and Mandelbrot, for whom chaos
entails an unpredictably open universe during which wisdom is restricted to local
sites and medical types can by no means exhaust the chances of the particular. But
this view doesn't mean that scientists have given up the hunt for international reasons of traditional phenomena, for chaos is conceived of as containing its own
form of order. Hayles envisions chaos as a double-edged sword: it may be viewed
either as a acceptance that sickness performs a extra very important function in natural
processes than had hitherto been well-known or as an extension of order into areas
that had hitherto resisted formalization. She examines constructions and subject matters of
disorder within the schooling of Henry Adams, Doris Lessing's Golden Notebook,
and works via Stanislaw Lem. Hayles concludes through exhibiting how the writings of
poststmcturalist theorists include principal beneficial properties of chaos theory-such as
an curiosity in bearing on neighborhood websites to worldwide stmctures; a perception of order and
disorder as interpenetrating instead of hostile; an wisdom that during complex
systems small factors can result in substantial results; and an figuring out that
complex platforms will be either deterministic and unpredictable.
Chaos sure will give a contribution to and brighten up present debates between chaos
theorists, cultural critics and cultural historians, serious theorists, literary
critics drawn to 19th- and twentieth-century literature, researchers in
nonlinear dynamics, and others serious about the relation among science
and tradition.

Extra resources for The Pseudoscience Wars: Immanuel Velikovsky and the Birth of the Modern Fringe

Example text

12 The book was, and remains, an enthralling read. It also required, to account for the events described—near collisions of planets, comets the size of Venus, the transformation of a hydrocarbon/petroleum tail of the comet into carbohydrate manna for the Israelites—outright contraventions or 22 CHAPTER ONE at least severe modifications of the conventional understandings of celestial mechanics, physics, chemistry, geology, paleontology, and biology. , which excluded shifts in the poles or the orbital orientation of Earth.

110 (Velikovsky, it should be said, was not at first enamored of this narrative: “To me it is most important to show that I was right. ”112 Here are two key assumptions: that the campaign was organized and that it failed. But the objections to Macmillan were scattered; in fact, in hindsight, one could easily say that the press overreacted to light pressure. The second point, about failure, requires a proper understanding of the boycott’s purpose. The Grand Collision of Spring 1950 43 It is tempting to look back on the uproar of spring 1950 and see it as so much hot air.

94 A form letter was drawn up to answer hostile correspondents, insisting that “Dr. ”96 This approach failed quickly. By May several scientists and departments—it is impossible to tell how many, and it was quite possibly only about five, but enough to be ominous—had turned away Macmillan representatives and sent back books. So Brett turned to his lawyers. F. ) Brett rapidly arranged a deal with the Doubleday publishing house to take over the Velikovsky contract—a coup for them, since they would be acquiring a best seller at no cost and had no textbook department to leave them vulnerable to boycotting.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.76 of 5 – based on 3 votes